The Study of Rhetoric Essay - 1038 Words

The Study of Rhetoric Works Cited Missing The study of rhetoric traditionally has aimed to equip students with an ability to identify problems and issues, to investigate, to interpret, and to communicate results -- whatever the subject matter. These abilities require higher-level thinking, not just skills; analysis and evaluation, not just observation . . . . The study emphasizes strategies and practice rather than a body of facts and contemplation; thus the study of rhetoric aims for social application. Students are studying rhetoric in a technical communication course even though they may never hear of Aristotle nor study history and theory of rhetoric. Identifying a problem, gathering, interpreting, and arranging information,†¦show more content†¦Because definitions are a product of rigid, formal thinking, quality cannot be defined. (ZMM -- Pirsig 206) Pirsig, a theorist as well as a rhetorician would see the approach as the right idea. Students should be faced with challenges that require demonstration of understanding as well as some demonstration of quality. I know that stating Pirsig feels students need to demonstrate some effort towards quality is reaching, but I think that is what he is truly looking for students (his in particular) to be able to understand and demonstrate. I feel that this is what you are trying to establish with us as students in your class as well. Flaws are found in this methodology of education, Pirsig sees that students need to be taught Quality but, †¦how are you to teach something that isnt premeditated? It was a seemingly impossible requirement. (Pirsig 176) Struggling with this concept leads one to believe that students must develop a sense of Quality based on what they feel. There is no prescriptive method to teach students to produce Quality. Pirsigs major problem with this whole concept is that he does not have a true understanding of Quality, and rightfully so. How is one supposed to determine Quality? Heres how Pirsig (in my eyes) might respond to Carolyn Rude; students should be introduced to methodology in order to make valid attempts but the answers are to be derived from students applying effort to a goal,Show MoreRelatedAnalysis Of A Lot Can Be Learned About Rhetoric, And The Integrity Of Women And Gender Studies Essay1912 Words   |  8 Pages A lot can be learned about rhetoric by looking at these two articles: â€Å"5 Charts That Show Sexism Is Still Alive and Well in Gaming† and â€Å"The Integrity of Women and Gender Studies†. One portrays the gaming community as sexist and underrepresenting women (Kleeman) while the other condemns modern feminism for treating women as victims and â€Å"vilifying† men (Frohlich). The first uses many logical arguments that are used to bring emotion to the reader, and make them feel like certain things are ethicallyRead More The Composition and Rhetoric Field Essay1051 Words   |  5 PagesComposition and Rhetoric (a.k.a. Writing Studies): A Flexible Field In his essay, Teach Writing as a Process not a Product, Donald Murray outlines the major difference between the traditional pedagogy that directed the teaching of writing in the past and his newly hailed model. Traditionally, Murray explains, English teachers were taught to teach and evaluate students writing as if it was a finished product of literature when, as he has discovered, students learn better if theyre taught thatRead MoreAristotle s Rhetoric And The Three Different Formations Of The Theory1260 Words   |  6 Pages(1996) states, â€Å"The proper aim of the rhetoric is that of finding the best available means of persuasion, whatever the subject me be (1355a4 ff., 1355b26 ff.)† (p. 1). This is exactly what Aristotle does through the use of the rhetoric and the three different formations of the theory he created. Aristotle was very adamant on the use of rhetoric when addressing an audience. Rorty (1996) claims that â€Å"Aristotle chides the authors of earlier handb ooks on rhetoric for concentrating primarily on techniquesRead MoreWeight Loss And Its Myths1665 Words   |  7 PagesThis however is a skill that is learned over time and calls for patience to master. This skill is the use of rhetoric to someone’s advantage. From a general point of view, rhetoric involves changing perception or understanding from their original to make them form a different opinion of the same thing. It may involve adding things that attract people and may not be necessarily true. Rhetoric can be used to help or deceive people, which is why it is important to know when it is being used just to beRead MoreRhetoric And Its Impact On The Modern Electronic Age1734 Words   |  7 PagesRhetoric is defined as the art or study of using language effectively and persuasively. Rhetoric in our electronic age has improved greatly due to technological advances since the practice of rhetoric was created. Major philosophers such as Andrea Lunsford, Lawrence Perill, Arist otle, and Sophist such as Gorgias and Protagoras have shown reasons why rhetoric is important and has improved over the many years dating back to Greek, Renaissance, and Roman times. Throughout the modern electronic age rhetoricRead MoreDr. Lamps Case For Tenure And Promotion1485 Words   |  6 Pagesrecommending Professor Lamp for tenure and promotion. Dr. Lamp is a scholar of rhetorical theory, practice, and education and joined the English department in fall semester 2010. Her published scholarship since arriving at ASU includes one book, The Rhetoric of Augustan Rome (2013, University of South Carolina Press), two refereed articles in major peer reviewed journals, and two book reviews. She also has one 3,000 word contribution in a refereed conference proceeding, which has been submitted for publicationRead More Aristotle and the Techne of Rhetoric Essay1447 Words   |  6 PagesAristotle and the Techne of Rhetoric Between the third and fifth centuries B.C. there existed a â€Å"golden and classical age† of thought in the ancient world, with the majority of this activity centered in the polis of Athens, Greece. Although the city is historically recognized for its legendary conflict with rival polis Sparta, Athens is perhaps best known for the creation of democracy—that noble political experiment that laid the preliminary structure for most of the rights we AmericansRead MoreRhetoric : The Power Of Discourse1689 Words   |  7 Pagesart of rhetoric has been present since the beginning of time. The birth of rhetoric is usually attributed to the Greeks as they presented us with ideas and theories about discourse. Famous philosophers such as Plato, the Sophists, and Aristotle presented us with theories that continue to be studied throughout. Most importantly the reason why we still study rhetoric is because rhetoric is everywhere. Our everyday lives are filled with the intensity of rhetoric and what it can do. Thus, rhetoric is theRead MoreThe Dark : The Evolution Of General Rhetoric, By George A. Kennedy1113 Words   |  5 PagesSpeculative, General Reflexive Rhetoric of Autopoietic Hooting Machines In his 1992 essay â€Å"A Hoot in the Dark: The Evolution of General Rhetoric,† George A. Kennedy proposed a foundation of and for a â€Å"General Rhetoric† that encompasses the activity of all social, communicative animals, a rhetoric as potential energy that exists prior to not only speech but to the whole of communication. Twenty-five years later, writing in the same journal, Philosophy and Rhetoric, and affiliated with the same institutionRead MoreElbow And Bartholomae Rhetoric Essay797 Words   |  4 PagesApplying â€Å"What is Rhetoric?† to Elbow’s and Bartholomaes Arguments The role of academic writing in a students life is largely contested among rhetoric and writing professors and academics. Covino and Joliffes article What is Rhetoric? and Elbow and Bartholomaes academic discussion both seek to define both what role academic is and what role writing should play in undergraduate studies. While What is Rhetoric? focuses more on finding one definitive definition of rhetoric, Elbow and Bartholomae